First Kill

Mike McFarland

Timothy Krajcir

Todd Jenkins

Bruce Chesser

April Hartman

Scissors Victim

Martha Harms

Brenda Parsh

Leticia Magaña

Mary Parsh

Rachel Dee

Donna Lauria

Maeghan Albach

Karen Chesser-Parsh

Susana Gibb

Gwen Thoma

Kerry McCormick

EMT

Sean McGraw

Floyd Parsh

Tom Costello Jr.

Interrogation Detective

Joshua Gage

Timothy Krajcir (5)

Allison Victoria-Wolfe

Krajcir's Wife

Dean Gosdin

Detective Jimmy Smith

Aaron M. Sanchez

Lauria Brother #1

Kris Mohandie

Self - Clinic and Forensic Psychologist

Joseph Coffey

Self - Detective, NYPD

Sam Swanson

Robert Violante